Fact checkPoliticsPublished October 3, 2026

Justice Samuel Alito: An individual standing in Mexico does not legally arrive in the United States by attempting to enter the country. Our verdict: True.

Justice Samuel Alito: An individual standing in Mexico does not legally arrive in the United States by attempting to enter the country. Our verdict: True.
Photo: Collection of the Supreme Court of the United States, Photographer: Steve Petteway / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain
Justice Samuel AlitoNews reportOctober 3, 2026

Justice Samuel Alito made the claim on 3 October 2026, as reported by ABC News in a story about the Supreme Court allowing asylum seekers to be turned away at the border.

Our verdict

True

The claim is accurate. The Supreme Court's decision in Mullin v. Al Otro Lado confirms that a person standing in Mexico has not legally arrived in the United States simply by trying to enter.

What we found

We checked the Supreme Court decision in Mullin v. Al Otro Lado. A legal case page from Cornell Law School records that the Court held an alien standing in Mexico does not 'arrive in the United States' by attempting, and failing, to set foot in the country. The Congressional Research Service says the Court ruled that people stopped on the Mexican side are not legally entitled to an inspection, which confirms they have not arrived under immigration law. We found no source that contradicts this.

The evidence

3 of 6 sources support the claim; none contradict it.

Contradict 0Support 3Background 3
When each source was published
23.211.139.208 · Jun 2026 · supports the claimmatthewvadum.com · Jun 2026 · backgroundcongress.gov · Jun 2026 · supports the claimJun 2026Jun 2026
  • Supports the claim

    The Cornell Law School page for Mullin v. Al Otro Lado records that the Supreme Court held an alien standing in Mexico does not 'arrive in the United States' by attempting, and failing, to set foot in the country. [1]

  • Supports the claim

    The Congressional Research Service says the Court ruled that people stopped on the Mexican side are not legally entitled to an inspection, so they have not arrived under immigration law. [2]

  • Supports the claim

    The Supreme Court opinion page records that the case concerns whether an alien standing in Mexico has 'arrived in the United States' under US immigration law. [3]

  • Background

    ABC News reported that Justice Alito wrote an opinion stating that an alien standing in Mexico has not 'arrived in the United States'. [4]

  • Background

    Matthew Vadum reported on the outcome of the Mullin v. Al Otro Lado decision, providing background on the ruling. [5]

  • Background

    A Facebook post by Judicial Watch attributes to the Supreme Court the statement that an alien standing in Mexico who tries but fails to set foot in the United States has not 'arrived' for asylum purposes. [6]

What we could not confirm

  • We did not find a clear legal definition of 'arrival' in the sources, so the conclusion depends on the Supreme Court ruling rather than a plain legal statement.

How we checked

We looked at the Supreme Court case page, the Congressional Research Service analysis, ABC News reporting, and related legal commentary. We reviewed 8 relevant sources.

Sources

Have evidence we missed?

If you know of a source that confirms or contradicts this claim, send us the link. We review every submission and update fact checks when new evidence changes the picture.

Measured Take updates fact checks when new evidence emerges. Corrections are noted on the page.

All fact checks