Donald Trump: Donald Trump threatened Democratic candidate Mary Peltola with criminal prosecution regarding allegations her campaign recruited a second candidate named Dan Sullivan in Alaska's Senate race. Our verdict: True.
Donald Trump made the threat on 8 November 2026, as reported by The Guardian, after Republican losses in the midterm elections.
Our verdict
True
Donald Trump did call for the criminal prosecution of Democratic Alaska Senate candidate Mary Peltola, and he tied that call to allegations that her campaign recruited a second candidate named Dan Sullivan. Multiple independent news organisations reported the threat and the link, so the claim is accurate.
What we found
We reached a verdict of true because several independent, reputable news organisations reported the same thing at the time. The Associated Press reported that Trump explicitly linked his call for prosecution to a New York Times report about the recruitment of a second Dan Sullivan. PBS NewsHour, AFP and the Alaska Beacon all reported that Trump called for Peltola to be prosecuted over the Sullivan name controversy, and The Guardian reported the same threat. The reports quote Trump directly, including the words "I think they should be prosecuted" and that Peltola should suffer the "Legal and Political consequences". FEC records confirm Peltola is a Democratic Senate candidate in Alaska and that a second candidate, Daniel J. Sullivan, filed for the same seat. Our check covers only whether the threat was made and tied to those reports. It does not judge whether the recruitment allegations themselves are true, nor whether any prosecution was legally justified or ever pursued.
The evidence
1 of 6 sources support the claim; none contradict it.
- Supports the claim
The Associated Press reported that Trump explicitly linked his call for prosecution to the New York Times report about the recruitment of a second Dan Sullivan. [1]
- Background
PBS NewsHour reported that Trump called for the prosecution of Mary Peltola following reports that her campaign was involved in recruiting a second candidate named Dan Sullivan. [2]
- Background
AFP reported that Trump publicly threatened Mary Peltola with criminal prosecution and demanded her removal from the ballot, citing an alleged recruitment of a second Dan Sullivan by Democratic operatives. [3]
- Background
The Alaska Beacon reported that Trump called for Peltola to be criminally charged and ordered a DOJ lawsuit over the Alaska Senate race, following New York Times reports about the recruitment of a second Dan Sullivan. [4]
- Background
The Guardian reported that Trump threatened Mary Peltola with criminal prosecution regarding allegations her campaign recruited a second Dan Sullivan in Alaska's Senate race. [5]
- Background
FEC records confirm Mary Peltola is a Democratic candidate for the U.S. Senate seat in Alaska, and a separate FEC record shows a candidate named Daniel J. Sullivan filed as a Republican challenger for the same seat in the 2026 cycle. [6]
What we could not confirm
- Whether the alleged recruitment of a second Dan Sullivan by Peltola's campaign actually happened. Our check only confirms that reports alleging it existed and that Trump's threat referenced them.
- The exact legal basis for Trump's call for prosecution, and whether any formal prosecution was ever pursued.
- Whether Peltola held candidate status at the precise moment of Trump's threat. FEC records confirm her filing, but contemporaneous news reports fill the gap on timing.
How we checked
We looked at contemporaneous news reports from the Associated Press, PBS NewsHour, AFP, The Guardian and the Alaska Beacon, and at Federal Election Commission candidate records for the Alaska Senate race. We compared what each source said about Trump's public statements and the candidates on the ballot. We reviewed 10 relevant sources.
Sources
- [1]apnews.com · Trump calls for prosecution of Democratic Alaska Senate candidate over spoiler candidate controversy · October 28, 2026
- [2]pbs.org · Trump calls for prosecution of Alaska Senate candidate Peltola over Sullivan name controversy · October 28, 2026
- [3]AFP · Trump demands Alaska Democrat off ballot after NY Times report
- [4]alaskabeacon.com · Republican officials order investigations of Peltola and other Democrats after New York Times report | Alaska Beacon · October 29, 2026
- [5]www.theguardian.com · Trump set to lurch further right, claiming US took ‘giant step back’ in elections · November 8, 2026
- [6]fec.gov · PELTOLA, MARY - Candidate overview - FEC.gov
Have evidence we missed?
If you know of a source that confirms or contradicts this claim, send us the link. We review every submission and update fact checks when new evidence changes the picture.
Measured Take updates fact checks when new evidence emerges. Corrections are noted on the page.
All fact checks