Andy Burnham: The UK has experienced more economic losses than gains as a result of Brexit. Our verdict: True.

Andy Burnham made the claim in a speech on 16 November 2026, reported by The Guardian, saying Brexit 'has not worked' and that he would sign a new deal with the EU.
Our verdict
True
Andy Burnham's claim that the UK has experienced more economic losses than gains from Brexit is supported by the evidence. Independent assessments point to lower GDP, reduced trade and falling foreign investment, while the gains from new trade deals are much smaller.
What we found
We found broad agreement among economic institutions that Brexit has left the UK worse off. The Office for National Statistics reported that in 2024 the UK's outward foreign direct investment position in the EU fell by £161.7 billion, and inward investment flows to the UK dropped by £27.9 billion compared with 2023. A guide to UK-EU relations from the UK in a Changing Europe project said there is a consensus that GDP is 2-3% lower now and 4% lower in the long run. The London mayor's office and the Centre for European Reform both cite Office for Budget Responsibility projections of a 4% long-run reduction in GDP and a 15% reduction in trade volume. The UK has gained full access to the CPTPP trading bloc, but the projected losses are far larger than the gains from that deal. On that basis, the claim is true.
The evidence
5 of 7 sources support the claim; none contradict it.
- Background
Andy Burnham said the UK has lost more than it gained from Brexit and that the Brexit deal 'has not worked'. [1]
- Supports the claim
In 2024, the UK's outward foreign direct investment position in the EU fell by £161.7 billion, and inward investment flows to the UK decreased by £27.9 billion compared with 2023. [2]
- Background
In the third quarter of 2026, UK goods exports to the EU fell by £2.3 billion (4.5%) compared with the second quarter, while goods exports to non-EU countries rose. [3]
- Supports the claim
There is a broad consensus that Brexit has had a significant negative impact on the UK economy, with GDP estimated to be 2-3% lower currently and 4% lower in the long run. [4]
- Supports the claim
The UK secured full access to the CPTPP trading bloc in September 2026. [5]
- Supports the claim
The Office for Budget Responsibility has projected a 4% long-run reduction in UK GDP and a 15% reduction in trade volume due to Brexit. [6]
- Supports the claim
The Office for Budget Responsibility and other studies estimate significant long-term GDP and productivity losses due to Brexit, and trade in both goods and services has decreased relative to a counterfactual. [7]
What we could not confirm
- The exact size of the losses is uncertain because much of the evidence relies on projections and comparisons with a scenario in which the UK stayed in the EU, rather than on realised historical data.
- Some sources present contradictory or ambiguous information about possible gains from Brexit, which we noted but could not resolve.
- The trade figures cover longer-term trends and may be affected by global shocks such as COVID-19 and geopolitical events that are not fully separated out.
How we checked
We looked at the original speech report, trade and investment data from the Office for National Statistics, and economic assessments from the UK in a Changing Europe project, the London mayor's office and the Centre for European Reform, as well as the government's announcement on CPTPP access. We reviewed 7 relevant sources.
Sources
- [1]www.theguardian.com · Andy Burnham to say Brexit ‘has not worked’ and he will sign new deal with EU · November 16, 2026
- [2]ons.gov.uk · Foreign direct investment involving UK companies - Office for National Statistics · December 31, 2024
- [3]ons.gov.uk · UK trade - Office for National Statistics · November 13, 2026
- [4]media.ukandeu.ac.uk · GUIDE TO UK-EU RELATIONS · September 1, 2024
- [5]gov.uk · UK secures full access to £13 trillion CPTPP trading bloc · September 1, 2026
- [6]london.gov.uk · Overview of recent studies on Brexit’s economic impacts · January 1, 2026
- [7]cer.eu · Ten years after the Brexit referendum: The past, present and future of the UK’s relationship with the EU · June 1, 2026
Have evidence we missed?
If you know of a source that confirms or contradicts this claim, send us the link. We review every submission and update fact checks when new evidence changes the picture.
Measured Take updates fact checks when new evidence emerges. Corrections are noted on the page.
All fact checks