UniCredit's Commerzbank win: consolidation cheer, competition questions
The EU's celebration of an unconditional approval for UniCredit's Commerzbank bid, alongside a call for 'perhaps half a dozen' global-scale lenders, reveal
UniCredit has won European Union and US Federal Reserve approval for its acquisition of Germany's Commerzbank, following the European Central Bank's green light last month. The European Commission's approval was unconditional. The hostile €45 billion approach for Germany's second-largest bank began two years ago, and if completed it would mark a significant step in European cross-border banking consolidation. On the same day, European financial services commissioner Maria Luis Albuquerque said the EU needs more cross-border bank mergers to create global-scale lenders capable of competing with the largest US and Chinese banks, noting that the bloc's 4,500-bank sector needs 'perhaps half a dozen' large banks while preserving diversity including smaller local lenders.
Those two facts sit together awkwardly. An unconditional clearance is not merely a decision about one deal; it is a signal about the direction of travel. When the same authority that is meant to police competition simultaneously says the sector needs fewer, larger institutions to be competitive, the safeguards it claims to protect start to look like an afterthought. The Commission's approval was unconditional, and officials have said growth must not come at the expense of customers. But the political framing around the deal — the explicit desire for European champions — makes it harder to argue that competition concerns were the primary filter through which the transaction was assessed.
The strongest case against this reading deserves to be stated plainly. The Commission's approval was unconditional, which means it did not attach remedies or conditions that would suggest it saw a competition problem requiring correction. European Commissioner Teresa Ribera said cross-border mergers can help create stronger European banks while safeguarding competition and choice, and added that growth must not come at the expense of customers. On that account, there is no evidence that the safeguards are being weakened: the deal was cleared on its merits, the existing rules were applied, and officials have explicitly reaffirmed that customer interests remain protected. The call for 'perhaps half a dozen' large banks is a statement of ambition about the EU's global standing, not a directive to ignore competition law. The two can coexist.
That answer is reasonable as far as it goes, but it does not fully address the tension. The problem is not that the Commission failed to apply its rules in this instance; it is that the political environment in which those rules operate is being reshaped. When a senior commissioner says the EU needs 'perhaps half a dozen' global-scale lenders, the message to national regulators and to the Commission itself is that scale is a virtue. That message does not need to be written into a decision to influence one. It shapes which deals get encouraged, which get waved through, and which get scrutinised. The 4,500-bank sector Albuquerque describes is not a static backdrop; it is the product of decades of consolidation and of rules designed to keep markets contestable. Preserving diversity including smaller local lenders while simultaneously encouraging the creation of half a dozen global giants is not impossible, but it is a balancing act that becomes harder to sustain once the political weight tilts decisively towards size.
There is also the question of what happens next. Commerzbank shareholders have not yet accepted the hostile €45 billion offer. The Fed and the EU have not said what conditions, if any, they attached to their approvals. The timeline for completing the acquisition is not yet known. Those are not minor procedural details; they are the points at which the competition safeguards will either prove robust or prove decorative. An unconditional approval today does not guarantee that the same approach will be taken when the next cross-border deal arrives, or the one after that. If the EU's stated ambition is to have 'perhaps half a dozen' banks of global scale, the logical consequence is more deals of this kind, and more pressure to clear them quickly.
The Commission is entitled to want European banks that can compete with the largest US and Chinese institutions. That is a legitimate policy goal. But it cannot simultaneously present itself as the guarantor of competition and choice while signalling that the sector needs to be radically reshaped in favour of scale. The safeguards are not hollow yet. The risk is that they become so gradually, one unconditional approval at a time, while officials insist that growth must not come at the expense of customers. The next test will be whether Commerzbank shareholders accept the offer, and whether the conditions attached to the approvals — if any are disclosed — match the rhetoric.
Sources
More from Business
Conversation
Reader notes
Loading comments...