Scottish election coverage misses Greens record and misstates pro‑independence tally
Fact check of Scottish Greens seat record, pro‑independence MSP total, and unverified Andrew Neil remarks about Scotland.

A group of young people dressed in green are all smiling and waving there arms in the air as they celebrate
TL;DR
The Scottish Greens returned a record eight MSPs in 2021. Pro‑independence MSPs number 72, not 73 as claimed. Andrew Neil’s alleged description of Scotland cannot be verified.
Claim 1 The Scottish Greens returned a record number of Members of the Scottish Parliament in the recent election.
Evidence Official results show the Greens won eight seats in the 2021 Scottish Parliament election, up from six seats in 2016.
Verdict Mostly true.
Analysis The eight‑seat total is the highest ever recorded for the party, confirming the record claim.
Claim 2 In the Scottish Parliament, 73 Members of the Scottish Parliament belong to pro‑independence parties, which is a record high.
Evidence The Scottish National Party secured 64 seats and the Greens eight seats, giving a combined total of 72 pro‑independence MSPs.
Verdict Mostly false.
Analysis The count falls one short of the claimed 73, so the statement overstates the pro‑independence total.
Claim 3 Andrew Neil stated that Scotland is rudderless and increasingly shabby, and that it suffers from urban squalor unmatched elsewhere in Western Europe.
Evidence No verifiable source for the alleged Daily Mail column containing the quotation has been provided.
Verdict Unverifiable.
Analysis Without a reliable transcript or link to the column, the claim cannot be confirmed or refuted.
Watch for how media outlets adjust their coverage of future Scottish elections as parties negotiate power sharing and independence debates continue.
Continue reading
More in this thread
Starmer Faces Revolt as 70 MPs Call for His Exit After Lacklustre Speech
Nadia Okafor
Israel’s Knesset Approves Death Penalty and Televised Trials for October 7 Detainees
Nadia Okafor
Reform UK Secures 11 Seats in Epping Forest and Takes Essex County Council
Nadia Okafor
Conversation
Reader notes
Loading comments...